Threat researchCisent
In half an hour, an AI solved the 25-year mystery of the curves that protect much of the internet
The seeds of NIST's curves, which the NSA handed over unexplained in 2000, weren't hiding a backdoor: they came from a 1990s random generator and the clock time.

On October 16, 2026, the answer to one of the oldest mysteries in modern cryptography was published: where the “seeds” of the elliptic curves that NIST, the US standards institute, published in 2000 came from. A team of researchers at an artificial intelligence company found it with an AI model, in under half an hour.12
What happened
P-256 and its sibling curves are used for signing and encryption across much of the internet. They were built from a set of starting numbers, the seeds, that the NSA handed over without explaining how it had chosen them.3 That’s why, for years, people suspected the agency might have picked them so the curves would have a weakness only it knew about.1
The story that circulated said the author of the seeds, an NSA cryptographer, had run a joke phrase through a hash function, and that the phrase had been lost.3 About three years ago, cryptographer Filippo Valsorda offered a bounty to whoever found the origin.1
There was no phrase. The seeds came from a standard pseudorandom number generator of the time, from the POSIX rand48 family, started with a computer’s clock time between May 1997 and April 1998. Anyone can now reproduce them.12
The researchers claimed the bounty on October 15. Valsorda reimplemented the method on his own to check it, and the money, US$ 36,864, was donated to ISRG, the nonprofit behind Let’s Encrypt.1
Why it matters
It’s good news for cryptography: it isn’t a flaw or a new attack, and nobody needs to change their keys.2 According to Valsorda, whoever chose the seeds had at most about 30 bits of freedom, too little to hide a weakness or a backdoor.1
The news is also about speed. A mystery that experts couldn’t solve in more than 25 years was solved by an AI model in under half an hour.2 That speed is on the attackers’ side too.
Something is still open: nobody knows why there are about twice as many valid seeds as were published, or what one of the two criteria for accepting each curve was.1
Where Cisent comes in
Sentinel Red Team uses AI agents to attack the organization’s systems with its authorization and within the scope it defines, at an attacker’s speed, to find the gaps before they do. It’s ongoing testing, not one audit a year, and every new attack pattern helps train the defense.
Sources
Filippo Valsorda, “The NIST Elliptic Curves Seeds Bounty Has Been Claimed”, October 16, 2026. https://words.filippo.io/seeds-solved/↩︎
Alan West, “Is NIST P-256 Backdoored? Its Seed Was a 1997 Unix Timestamp”, DEV Community, October 18, 2026. https://dev.to/alanwest/is-nist-p-256-backdoored-its-seed-was-a-1997-unix-timestamp-1f94↩︎
Stephen A. Weis, “How were the NIST ECDSA curve parameters generated?”, 2023, updated in 2026. https://saweis.net/posts/nist-curve-seed-origins.html↩︎